Why your board should have written, updated Committee Charters
Do your Audit, Nomination, Remuneration or other committees have written, updated charters setting out the roles and responsibilities of each committee? Have these been discussed and agreed at board level?
As described in our recent article What is a Board Charter and why is it important?, Committee Charters (sometimes called Terms of Reference) are just as important as the overall Board Charter. Charters help ensure clarity and alignment, since it not a “given” that all board members understand the purpose and tasks of the committees.
The purpose of each committee is to support the board by working on specifically agreed tasks, preparing material, and creating recommendations. The committee should bring its recommendations and support material to board meetings and ensure enough time is allocated for the board to discuss and make decisions.
Be careful to ensure the committees do not overtake the decision making. This can easily happen, as many committee members are very engaged and board members outside of the committee trust the committees and are happy to delegate the details. However, the entire board is responsible for making decisions, and needs to pay attention to how the committees function.
There are many ways to write a Committee Charter, and one good example comes from Pennon Group, a publicly listed British water utility company, with their committee responsibilities listed here. https://www.pennon-group.co.uk/about-us/board-committees . As can be seen in their charter (Terms of Reference) for the Nomination Committee, the document covers areas such as: how the Committee members and chair will be appointed and for how long; what type of quorum (number and independence) is necessary for conducting committee business; frequency of meetings; notice of meetings; routine for the minutes; how the Committee will engage with shareholders; a full list of the Committee’s duties; and reporting responsibilities.
Ideally, the Committee Charter should also contain information about whether all committee agendas, material and minutes of committee meetings will be available for the entire board and selected senior executives, via the board’s digital platform (such as BoardVantage, Admincontrol, Diligent etc.). Committees often forget to have clear and transparent rules laid out for this.
Another important area which many boards forget to cover in the Committee Charter is the area of risk. The board is responsible for handling company risks, so it can be a good exercise for the board to regularly list all major risks and ensure each is delegated to the most relevant committee. The risk of not having a strong CEO back-up plan is different, for example, than the risk of health and safety issues or the risk of currency fluctuation, so these would each go to the suitable committee to ensure no risks are left unexamined.
The benefits of having updated Committee Charters cannot be overstated. It can be an excellent idea for your board to take time every year to review what your peer companies are doing in this area, in order to benchmark yourselves and strive for continuous improvement.
For more information or for help developing a Committee Charter, please contact us at